Sacrificed

Sacrificed is the seventh episode of Survivor: All-Stars.

Day 18 (Night)
An hour after blindsiding Reniero from the game, the remaining four members of Mogo Mogo return to camp, with most of the attention on Sheamus, who was the only person to stay loyal to the original plan.

Chapera
Teddy reads Tree Mail aloud to the camp, informing them that for the upcoming reward challenge they must send one individual over to the rival camp to select three items to loot, with these three items being what they are playing for.

The entire tribe is unanimous in accepting Holly's request to go, sending her on the boat to select items from Mogo Mogo's camp. After she's gone, several tribe members joke that they're enjoying her departure from camp.

Mogo Mogo
Similarly, the Mogo Mogo tribe deliberate over which of them should be sent to Chapera, having narrowed it down to Danni and Mina.

Chapera
Danni arrives at Chapera's camp, being greeted fondly by everyone, somewhat overcoming the awkwardness at being reunited with Ben.

Whilst looking around, Danni, Teddy and William get a private moment by the shelter, as Ben and Adela sit several metres away. The trio whisper, wanting to share some information after their separation at Saboga's dissolution.

The tribe and Danni all head out together, being informed that they will be reunited with Holly and the rest of Mogo Mogo at the reward challenge.

Mogo Mogo
Holly looks around Mogo Mogo's camp after being given the information that Reniero was the one voted out, something which surprises her. She attempts to pry for more information, but is given virtually nothing by the three present Mogo Mogo members.

Reward Challenge
Challenge: Log Jam

Log-rolling competition. Last one standing wins.

Reward: Any three items from losing tribe's camp

Information: The tribes play to five points. Teddy and William sit-out for Chapera, both fearing their balance may not be up to scratch. For the first match-up, Adela takes on Danni, with Adela scoring the point for Chapera. For the second match-up, Ben takes on Abbas, with the point going to Mogo Mogo. Sheamus wins Mogo Mogo a second point after his match-up against Isaiah. However, Holly ties it up at 2-2 after beating Mina in the fourth match-up. Adela manages to beat Danni once again, giving Chapera a lead of 3-2. But, Mogo Mogo gain another two points when Abbas and Sheamus once again win their match-ups against Ben and Isaiah respectively. In the eighth match-up, Mina is able to stay on and outlast Holly, giving Mogo Mogo a fifth point and ultimately winning them reward.

Winner: Mogo Mogo

Chapera
The entire Chapera tribe and Danni return to their camp, as Danni begins taking the items that she opted to loot (fishing spear, half a bag of rice and a bottle of alcohol). Danni apologises for what she takes, but is assured by Adela that they understand it's "nothing personal".

The tribe wave Danni off as she leaves, grateful that her loot hasn't completely crippled them. However, the tribe seem somewhat concerned, having been reminded that whilst Mogo Mogo were on a losing streak, that they are still able to beat Chapera in challenges.

Mogo Mogo
Danni returns to the Mogo Mogo camp with the newly won looted items, hoping that the tribe is pleased with what she selected. The foursome opt to share the alcohol between themselves, celebrating their first victory since swapping into a new tribe.

Tribe Gathering
The final ten contestants are gathered together, standing on opposite mats before being addressed by Jeff. He tells them that they must line-up, alternating between themselves in selecting which member of the opposite tribe they'd like to have time getting to know. After selection, the pairs are as follows: Isaiah and Sheamus, Adela and Abbas, William and Mina, and Teddy and Danni. Ben and Holly are left unpicked by anyone, leaving them to spend further time together during the 'getting to know you'.

Elsewhere, the other pairs talk through the general overview of the game. Adela and Abbas both keep their cards close to their chests, failing to fall into verbal traps put out by one another. William and Mina appear to have a good rapport with one another, laughing throughout their conversation, which remains mostly personal rather than being about the game. Isaiah and Sheamus catch up, having maintained a friendship after their time in The Amazon.

The final pairing of Teddy and Danni naturally get along well, having spent the first half of the game playing together. They discuss their hopes that both can make it through another tribal council and team up at the merge.

All ten contestants are brought back and separated once again onto their tribe mats. Jeff begins talking once again, hoping that they've enjoyed the chance to get to know those who've been on the other tribe.

Abbas is next to pull a buff, also joining Mina and Sheamus on the new Mogo Mogo tribe. Danni is the final member of Mogo Mogo to pull a buff, ending up on the Chapera tribe, being separated from those she's spent the past few days with.

Danni and Ben awkwardly hug, laughing due to the prospect that they're once again playing alongside each other. Teddy pulls a red buff next, joining Ben and Danni on the Chapera tribe, which Jeff jokingly dubs "a Borneo reunion". Holly is the next to join the Chapera tribe, pleased to be staying at her original camp. Isaiah pulls the next buff, being the fifth and final member of the Chapera tribe, ecstatic to be sticking alongside his closest ally Ben.

Chapera
The new Chapera tribe arrive back at camp, with Danni as the only new member after the last tribe swap. Danni keeps her arm around Teddy as she's given a short tour around her new home, clearly feeling awkward at being the odd-woman out on her new tribe. Holly does her best to make Danni comfortable, not wanting her to feel uncomfortable during her stay.

The three Borneo-alumni laugh over having ended up together, with there still being a sense that whilst they are joking, there is much uncertainty between ex-enemies Ben and Danni. Ben takes Holly off into the jungle to talk alone, leaving Isaiah with Danni and Teddy back at camp. The pair initially talk about their feeling of luck based on how the swap went, but eventually voice their concern for Adela, knowing that she will likely be voted out if Mogo Mogo lose the challenge.

Throughout the rest of the day, the Chapera tribe have an awkward tension in the air. Danni predictably tries to spend time bonding with Holly, having isolated her as the swing-vote needed to give her and Teddy a majority. Ben and Isaiah equally spend time with Teddy, wanting to see if they can establish where his loyalties will be in the case of their losing.

Mogo Mogo
After the tribe switch, the new Mogo Mogo tribe returns to camp, with Abbas, Mina and Sheamus having managed to stay together throughout the entire pre-merge phase thus far.

After showing the pair around camp, the five sit down to eat their first meal together, speculating that they will easily beat the new Chapera tribe in a strength based challenge. William offers to do some spear fishing for the tribe, joking that he's finally got an opportunity "now Teddy isn't around to hog it". Mina goes with him, helping to bag up any caught fish.

Mina tells William that she'd personally be willing to guarantee his safety if he votes with the Mogo Mogo trio against Adela, and that the original Chapera tribe are the "most dangerous" players moving forward.

Chapera
Before the immunity challenge, Ben sits by the fire pondering the thought of going to tribal council, knowing that whilst risky, it would be better for his overall game rather than to almost certainly lose his closest ally Adela should Mogo Mogo be the ones to lose.

Immunity Challenge
Both tribes arrive at the challenge, taking their seats on a set of parallel benches. Jeff informs them that they will be asked questions on the past seven seasons of Survivor, and that the first tribe to score eight points will win immunity.

The Chapera tribe look to Isaiah, who tries to play dumb in order to get the question wrong. Eventually, Danni is able to identify Delma and Edweena by default, saying it's the only answer that could make sense. Sheamus is able to get the same answer for Mogo Mogo, giving both tribes a second point.

Ben pressures his tribe to say "Reniero and Daisy", whilst Sheamus correctly leads his tribe into "Reniero and Neasa". Mogo Mogo scores a fourth point, whilst Chapera remain on two. Ben apologises to his tribe, trying to maintain the facade that his is trying his best. For the fifth question, the tribes are asked 'Which contestant was called a "ghostbuster" by their tribe?'. Teddy and Danni both correctly push their tribe to answer 'Uri', with Mogo Mogo also knowing the answer to the question.

Both tribes answer true, taking some time to deliberate. The answer is proven to be true, bringing Mogo Mogo's score up to six, and Chapera to four.

Mina snatches the pen for her tribe, writing down 'bracelet'. For Chapera, Ben tries to get his tribe to write down necklace, which he is ultimately successful in doing. Upon the reveal, Jeff confirms the item was a bracelet, giving Mogo Mogo a seventh point, whilst Chapera remain on four.

Immunity Challenge: Survivor History

The survivors will be quizzed about the show's seven-season history. The first tribe to score eight points wins immunity.

Winner: Mogo Mogo

Chapera
The tribe return to camp having lost the immunity challenge, mostly thanks to Ben's tactical wrong answers to give Mogo Mogo the win. Despite the loss, everyone seems oblivious to the fact Ben threw the challenge, with only Isaiah having been clued in to the plan. Ben, Holly and Isaiah spend some time together, with Holly telling the two boys that Teddy and Danni have both approached her about voting for Ben, which she says she won't do due to fears of being at the bottom of the opposing alliance. Ben thanks her for her honesty, pitching that by staying together they're giving themselves a good chance of reaching the top four with Adela.

The group separate after Ben and Isaiah agree that voting Teddy would be their best move, leaving Holly to return to camp where she continues conversing with Danni and Teddy, who she tells that voting out Ben would be a power play. Danni asks who Ben and Isaiah are voting for, to which Holly replies that they're "unsurprisingly" voting for Danni.

Meanwhile, Ben and Isaiah talk together about the vote, admitting that they're not feeling confident that even if Teddy goes home, that they'll be in any position to control the game.

The boys go through with their plan, having Isaiah take Holly off alone later in the day, leaving Teddy, Danni and Ben sat around the fire.

Ben continues the discussion around Holly's attempts at riding the middle, with the trio bonding over the fact that none of them completely trust Holly. Ben continues to reveal information that Holly gave them concerning Teddy and Danni's conversation with her, convincing them that she has in fact sided more with Isaiah and Ben.

The three seem to agree on the vote against Holly, with Isaiah and Holly returning soon after. Danni and Holly again have another conversation, in which Holly claims to be on board with voting Ben. Danni asks her if she thinks Ben suspects it, which Holly replies to with "he has no idea". Danni ponders whether or not she should turn the vote back around onto Ben, warning Holly that she's now a potential target. At tribal council, the group talks through their surprise at having not faced a merge yet, along with their reactions to the unprecedented late tribe-switch. Isaiah mentions that whilst the swap took him by surprise, that it serves as a reminder to never become sure about what to expect in Survivor. As the odd-person out, Danni is asked about how she feels being up against four new-Chapera members. She mentions that whilst she's nervous being presented as the easy vote, she believes there have been enough cracks that give her "at least somewhat of a fighting chance".

Jeff asks Teddy whether or not there is a group consensus heading into the vote, or if the result is likely to be split. He tells Jeff that it could be either or, as he's heard multiple names and been apart of multiple group conversations.

Ben somewhat defends Holly, saying that in the game people have different play styles, with Holly agreeing to this. Jeff notes that Isaiah has stayed unusually quiet throughout the tense conversation, which he jokingly replies to by saying "I'm just trying to slide into that merge", causing the other four to laugh.

Jeff places down the final revealed 'Holly' vote, which has a name scribbled out before it. Holly ignores her tribe as she grabs her torch, trying to come to terms with her surprising blindside at the hands of what she thought was an alliance with Ben and Isaiah. Before leaving, Holly wishes only Danni luck, with Isaiah shrugging to Teddy at their lack of well-wishes. The four remaining Chapera members grab their torches and head back to camp, hoping that the newly formed 'six person alliance' will prove successful enough to carry them through the rest of the game.

Trivia

 * This episode was originally incorrectly simulated, as the writer failed to take into account the pre-merge tribe switch. In the incorrect version of events, Chapera lost the challenge and Holly was still voted out, but in a 5-2 vote (with Ben voting against Teddy alongside her). The episode was re-simulated with the tribe swap, taking into account the same relationships and challenge performances, thus the similar result occurring. It did not impact the remainder of the season.
 * Holly was also initially incorrectly placed on the jury. This was corrected after the re-simulation.